Switchful Logo

Xfinity home security reviews

Xfinity brand
Staff rating
3.8
Installation: ProMonitoring: $30/mo.Equipment: $360+Contract: None
staff review
We're committed to rigorous research, first-hand experience, and transparency in our rating methodology. We don't accept sponsored placements or allow partner compensation to impact our ratings. Learn more about how we rate providers.

Headshot of Brittany McGhee
Headshot of Dave Schafer
Researched by
Headshot of Bri Field
Reviewed by
Bri FieldAssigning Editor
Updated 6/24/24

We’re committed to transparency. We may earn money when you follow our recommendations, but compensation doesn’t affect our ratings. Learn more.

Xfinity is well known and well respected, but be prepared for a premium price

Xfinity has a strong track record as a home security leader, but you’ll pay a lot to have its name on your yard sign. DIYers and renters will want to look elsewhere, but for the homeowner who wants the Xfinity reputation and doesn’t mind the price, it’s a very solid choice.

A sunset in a snowy land with a cabin
Meteor shower art over a dark forest
alt text
A very pink tree on a floating island
Same as before

Methodology: We had Xfinity professionally installed and tested its equipment and monitoring service. To write the most comprehensive and helpful review, we also hands-on tested some of Xfinity's biggest competitors to draw accurate comparisons and identify pros and cons. As we continue to use and build on our system, we’ll revisit this review to provide updated, experience-driven guidance.

  • We spent 6 hours speaking with Xfinity's sales representatives and documenting the installation process
  • We tested 10 Xfinity devices, including the control panel, motion detector, door and window sensors, indoor cameras, and environmental sensors
  • We contacted customer support on 2 channels and dug through Xfinity's knowledge base


What we like

  • Excellent smart home compatibility
  • Intuitive controls and customization
  • Impressive professional monitoring
What we don't like

  • Long installation times
  • Sometimes clunky equipment
  • High upfront and monthly costs
Savings tip: Providers often have
sign-up promotions
for first-time customers.
Check Xfinity's website
for current deals and discounts.
Check deals

Our expert assessment

Equipment and Customization
4.0
Great control panel, but otherwise lacking the “wow” factor

ADT has long been at the forefront of the home security industry, and as such, offers nearly every piece of equipment you could want to protect your home. From stalwart devices like motion detectors and security cameras to more modern ones like doorbell cameras and smart home devices, you’ll have little issue tailoring your system to your home.

Unfortunately, you can’t purchase ADT online. To order, you’ll need to call and speak with a sales agent, who will ask you some basic questions about your needs, such as how many doors and ground-level windows you have. They’ll also ask you about your preferences, like types of cameras, environmental sensors, and smart home systems.

You’ll also need to consider whether you want devices from Google (which partners with ADT), or ADT-branded ones. ADT’s devices are white-labeled, meaning they’re made by a third-party manufacturer, but it also means greater compatibility with other systems and devices. We opted for ADT’s devices, knowing we could tack on Google or other brands down the road.

ADT offers some order transparency before you call, but not much. While its website sheds light on its available packages and pricing, you won’t really know what’s in them until you call.

ADT only has three packages available:

  • The Secure Package includes the basics like the control panel, door and window sensors, and motion detectors
  • The Smart Package includes the basics plus smart plugs and lights
  • The Video & Smart Home Package includes all of the above, plus camera options

While ADT doesn’t highlight its individual products, it does have solid smart home compatibility. ADT has native compatibility with Google via its direct partnership, so you’ll find that you can pair Nest cameras, thermostats, control panels, and a bevy of other Google devices directly to your home security system with little trouble. And it connects easily to other smart home systems too, using IFTTT (If This Then That) integration. So, the vast majority of your smart devices (Alexa, Samsung, etc.) will also connect seamlessly.

Dynamic tablewithsmart homecompatibility
Sed ut perspiciatis omnis istetotam remsit voluptatem
Sed ut perspiciatis omnis istetotam remsit voluptatem
Sed ut perspiciatis omnis istetotam remsit voluptatem
Sed ut perspiciatis omnis istetotam remsit voluptatem
Sed ut perspiciatis omnis istetotam remsit voluptatem

Once you know exactly how you want to build your system out, you’ll schedule an installation time. When our technician arrived, he carefully walked us through every device we ordered (and some we didn’t, too).

We were immediately impressed by the look and functionality of the control panel, which stands out by its sleek design and appears to be able to stand the test of time. And there are some features of the panel that we really like. First, it connects to ADT’s monitoring centers via radio signal. Some competitors, like Cove and Alder, connect via SIM card to cellular networks—both of which gave us headaches when we tested those systems. The other features we really liked were that the panel’s camera snaps a photo of whomever arms or disarms the system (otherwise, it doesn’t run continuously), and it has a “clean screen” function that lets you wipe off fingerprints without accidentally setting off your alarm.

Placeholder image

After that, unpackaging the other devices felt a little anticlimactic. They looked and felt overly simple and didn’t project the “wow” factor that the control panel did. Of course, that didn’t matter for some of the devices—such as the door, window, and motion sensors—for which less is probably more. But others, like the combination heat, smoke, and carbon monoxide detector, were extremely bulky and cheap-looking and wouldn’t do most ceilings any favors.

Placeholder

If the control panel and environmental sensors represent both ends of the spectrum, the cameras rest somewhere in the middle. The ADT cameras are simple and fairly nondescript. We’ve seen better-looking cameras out there, such as Vivint’s, but overall we’re very happy with our ADT ones. They have strong bases that aren’t susceptible to tipping over (which is the problem with Vivint’s more aesthetically pleasing cameras), experience little lag time on the video feed, and have a really high-quality 1080p HD picture. They also have a decent field of view at 145 degrees (practically speaking, that’s about the same as a typical line of sight).

Placeholder

Up front, we weren’t sure what to expect with our equipment. On the one hand, ADT is extremely customizable and carries a wide selection of devices. On the other, we had no idea what that equipment was until we called. We also expected every device to blow us away with their looks and quality. The control panel definitely met our expectations. The rest? Time will tell.

Customization is key to the right home security system. Visit
Xfinity's website
to find the right offering.
View packages
We stand by the validity of our reviews and are committed to transparency: Our team uses consumer sentiment software to source customer reviews, which are entirely unique to this website. Reviewers attest to being current customers of the providers they review and are not incentivized to speak positively or negatively about their experience. We do not alter the reviews in any way. Learn more about how we source reviews.